17th January 2022

Using blind hiring to promote greater workplace diversity

Recruitment

The answer to bias during the recruitment process

It is far from a new idea, but using the process of blind hiring to select people with the best skills and abilities may seem a very obvious way to ensure that bias is removed from the recruitment process.

Blind hiring traces its origins back to 1952. Worried about the male domination of its ranks, the Boston Symphony Orchestra started auditioning musicians blind, asking them to perform behind a screen. From there the practice spread, first to other orchestras, and then into the wider world.

Today, removing names and ages from CVs, broadly anonymising applications, is an easy first step, and helps to prevent any prejudice creeping in, at least at the sifting stage.

Of course with ATS systems in widespread use to search for skills and qualifications keywords, many are already practising blind hiring as they whittle down candidates to the shortlist. Despite its ability to promote diversity, research suggests that only 35% of UK businesses practice blind recruitment in some shape or form. Given how issues such as the glass ceiling, gender imbalances and ‘equal pay for equal work’ are hot topics, this is rather surprising.

Research from the US shows the influence of bias:

But what happens beyond the shortlist at the sharp end of the search and selection process? Recruiters and hiring managers are likely to engage directly with candidates and this means that the effort made to obscure candidate demographics in the initial stages may be pointless.

Does blind hiring really work for business recruitment?

So, how can hiring processes continue blind when recruiters need to properly engage with candidates?

Technology has a role to play here. Ordinarily, it is difficult to maintain anonymity when talking on the phone, in a video interview, or person-to-person. However, it is possible by disguising speech and by using physical screening. It is also possible to conduct an interview over chat apps and to some extent, by using anonymised questionnaires.

Of course blind hiring has many critics, despite major names like HSBC, Deloitte, the BBC, and Google using the technique to ensure they’re hiring the best talent. One criticism is that beyond skills, experience, hobbies and interests, there’s not much a CV can tell you about a person. You really have to meet them. Many recruiters need to read facial expressions and body language and want to see how people speak and present themselves.

Another negative view is that what works for selecting an orchestra’s musicians doesn’t transpose to other walks of life or business. Essentially, how a musician performs a piece of music encapsulates their entire professional skillset, as well as their experience and personality. Such things cannot be fully conveyed using CVs and application forms.

Like psychometric testing and Myers-Briggs, blind recruiting is another technique that divides recruiters! It is simply one that every agency and recruiter needs to be aware of and it may be a personal belief about whether it has any merits and is of any use.

Avoid the peril of getting left behind with ETZ

Technology used to divide people. While some hated change and the march of progress, many embraced it. However, today you resist technology at your peril, because you are likely to get left behind.

ETZ’s market leading timesheet, invoicing and payment solution lets recruitment agencies transform efficiency of back office processing, for all agency workers and contractors. Streamlining admin through software automation ensures your agency doesn’t get left behind in the ceaseless quest for competitive advantage. To find out more about how we simplify the complexity of RecTech for agencies like yours, call us on 0800 311 2266 or book a demo.



Download your free guide

7 smart ideas to grow your recruitment agency.

Download Now
Download your free guide

Latest Posts

Recruitment

Up the value chain – Increasing agency returns through deal-makingUp the value chain – Increasing agency returns through deal-making

13th May 2022

Embodying the entrepreneurial spirit of recruitment The true entrepreneurial spirit that characterises much of the recruitment sector is embodied by...

Read more
Recruitment

Looking at the talent shortage through the lens of job securityLooking at the talent shortage through the lens of job security

6th May 2022

The certainty of predictable demand and job security The worst effects of Covid on businesses may have passed (for now,...

Read more
Recruitment

Hybrid working rejected by some despite data suggesting productivity boostsHybrid working rejected by some despite data suggesting productivity boosts

2nd May 2022

Some still not getting ‘the thing’ about hybrid working… Although China seems to be a notable exception, in many countries...

Read more

See what ETZ could do for your agency with an online demo

Save hassle, time and money with our powerful software.

Book a Demo

Sign Up To Our Newsletter